If you don’t have a lot of time and just want to get the gist of this article, here’s the summary:
In all my modest opinion, the Shimano 105 is a high-quality rear derailleur designed primarily for road cycling. I believe its 10-speed capability, large 11-tooth pulleys, and the flexibility to be used with both double and triple cranks, make it a wise choice for experienced cyclists seeking smooth and speedy gear changes. On the other hand, its lightweight nature of 243 grams can be enticing for those who are conscious about their gear’s weight. I also reckon its inclusion in the Shimano 105 group, known for its durability and good value, adds a touch of reliability to this piece.
However, the Shimano 105 might not be the perfect fit for everyone. For instance, mountain bikers or those into off-road cycling might find its features not rugged enough for their needs. Casual cyclists or those who enjoy leisure rides might find its 10-speed capability and weight-conscious design unnecessary. Lastly, those preferring a simple setup might view its versatility with double and triple cranks as somewhat complex.
Overall, I believe it’s about finding the right equipment that fits your unique cycling style, needs, and goals. And for some, the Shimano 105 might just be that perfect companion for the road.
Quick links:
Shimano 105 RD-5701-GS 10-Speed Rear Derailleur Review: Who is it for?
In my humble opinion, the Shimano 105 RD-5701-GS 10-Speed Rear Derailleur, or simply the Shimano 105 for ease of reference, is a piece of gear that finds its best use among a particular set of cyclists. Its features and technical specs suggest it is designed for those who engage in road cycling. Now, this doesn’t mean casual cyclists or absolute beginners wouldn’t benefit from it, but it seems to me that it’s really geared towards folks who already have a certain level of experience under their belt.
To start with the basics, the Shimano 105 is a rear derailleur, making it a crucial part of your bike’s drivetrain. It has an impressive 10-speed capability, which, in my opinion, would greatly appeal to those who thrive on long rides and enjoy having a variety of gear choices. The speed feature indicates that it’s meant for cyclists who need a derailleur capable of smooth and quick gear changes on varied road terrain.
The Shimano 105 boasts large 11-tooth pulleys with sealed bearings. Now, I think this feature is particularly appealing for those who value smooth and quiet running. So, if you’re the kind of cyclist who enjoys peaceful rides and values equipment that operates seamlessly, then this might be the derailleur for you.
The Shimano 105 also has some flexibility in its use. It has a 30t max rear cassette cog when used with a triple crank and a 32t when used with a double crank. This flexibility, in my view, suggests that it’s a good fit for cyclists who use both triple and double crank setups, thereby making it a versatile choice.
When it comes to weight, the Shimano 105 weighs 243 grams. Now, this might not make much of a difference to a casual cyclist, but for those who are conscious about the weight of their cycling gear, this may be a key consideration. This lightweight feature might be particularly appealing to those who are into competitive cycling or those who are simply after optimizing their speed and efficiency on the road.
It’s also worth noting that the Shimano 105 is part of the Shimano 105 group, which has a reputation for offering excellent, long-lasting performance balanced with good value. So, in my opinion, if you’re someone who values durability and cost-effectiveness in your cycling gear, then the Shimano 105 might be a product you’d want to consider.
In summary, based on its features and technical specs, I believe that the Shimano 105 is best suited for road cyclists who have a certain level of experience, who value a versatile and smooth-operating derailleur, and who appreciate lightweight and durable gear. However, as with any cycling gear, it’s always a good idea to do your own research, consider your own needs and preferences, and make an informed decision. After all, cycling is a personal journey, and the best gear is the one that best supports your unique cycling style and goals.
Shimano 105 RD-5701-GS 10-Speed Rear Derailleur Review: Who isn’t it for?
It seems to me that the Shimano 105 Rear Derailleur isn’t the best fit for everyone, especially when considering its features and technical capabilities. Let’s discuss some scenarios where this product might not be the best match.
For starters, if you’re someone who prefers off-road biking or mountain biking, the Shimano 105 might not be the right fit for you. It’s primarily designed for road cycling, and its large 11-tooth pulleys and specific max rear cassette cog configurations might not offer the range of gear ratios or the ruggedness needed for tackling rough terrains or steep climbs typically found in off-road trails. Based on my understanding, off-road biking demands a derailleur that can withstand more wear and tear, something that the Shimano 105, despite its durability, might not be perfectly suited for.
The Shimano 105 also offers a 10-speed capability. Now, while some might find a wide range of gears advantageous, I think if you’re a casual cyclist who merely enjoys leisurely rides around the city or in the park, you might not require such a wide gear range. In fact, it might even complicate matters for you. You see, having too many gears could potentially lead to more frequent maintenance and adjustments, not to mention the learning curve to get used to shifting through all those gears effectively.
Based on the weight specification of the Shimano 105, it seems to be designed with weight-conscious cyclists in mind. At 243 grams, it’s relatively light, which is great for competitive cyclists or those who are constantly looking to optimize their performance by shaving off every possible gram. However, if you’re not too bothered about the weight of your bike or if you’re more of a casual cyclist, this lightweight feature might not hold much value for you. In other words, you could potentially find a cheaper option that weighs a bit more but meets all your basic cycling needs.
Lastly, the Shimano 105’s versatility in being able to be used with both double and triple cranks might be a bit too much for some. If you’re a newbie cyclist or someone who prefers a simple and straightforward setup, the varying max rear cassette cog with double and triple cranks could be needlessly complex.
In conclusion, while the Shimano 105 is a fantastic derailleur with lots of features and capabilities, it might not be the best fit for those who are into off-road biking, casual cyclists who prefer simpler gear setups, and individuals who are not particularly concerned about the weight of their equipment. As with everything else, it’s always best to consider your personal needs, cycling habits, and preferences before making a decision. After all, the best cycling gear is the one that fits your unique style and requirements, not necessarily the one with the most features or the lightest weight.
Shimano 105 RD-5701-GS 10-Speed Rear Derailleur Review: Conclusion
In all my modest opinion, the Shimano 105 is a high-quality rear derailleur designed primarily for road cycling. I believe its 10-speed capability, large 11-tooth pulleys, and the flexibility to be used with both double and triple cranks, make it a wise choice for experienced cyclists seeking smooth and speedy gear changes. On the other hand, its lightweight nature of 243 grams can be enticing for those who are conscious about their gear’s weight. I also reckon its inclusion in the Shimano 105 group, known for its durability and good value, adds a touch of reliability to this piece.
However, the Shimano 105 might not be the perfect fit for everyone. For instance, mountain bikers or those into off-road cycling might find its features not rugged enough for their needs. Casual cyclists or those who enjoy leisure rides might find its 10-speed capability and weight-conscious design unnecessary. Lastly, those preferring a simple setup might view its versatility with double and triple cranks as somewhat complex.
Overall, I believe it’s about finding the right equipment that fits your unique cycling style, needs, and goals. And for some, the Shimano 105 might just be that perfect companion for the road.